Aquarium heater not working: troubleshooting and heater size guide

Aquarium Heater Not Working? Stuck On, Not Heating or Blinking (and What Size You Need)

Spread the love

A heater problem can go wrong fast in either direction. If it stops working, the water slowly cools and tropical fish get stressed and sick. If it sticks on, it can overheat a tank in a few hours. Here is how to tell what’s wrong, what to do right away, and what size heater your tank actually needs.

Affiliate Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I also earn a commission on purchases made through my Walmart, eBay and Hygger links. This helps support FinTastik Tropical Fish and allows me to keep providing free guides for aquarium and tropical fish keepers.

Quick answer: If the water is too hot, unplug the heater right away and cool the tank slowly. If it’s too cold, check the outlet, the dial setting and the indicator light, and confirm the temperature with a second thermometer. If the glass is cracked or water got inside, unplug it and replace it. For most tanks, plan on about 3 to 5 watts per gallon, and use two smaller heaters on big tanks.

Safety First

  • Always unplug a heater before you put your hands in the tank or take the heater out.
  • Let it cool for 15 to 30 minutes before lifting it out of the water. A hot glass heater can crack when it hits cooler air.
  • Never run a heater out of water, even for a minute, unless the manufacturer says it is safe.
  • Plug aquarium equipment into a GFCI outlet and leave a drip loop in each cord, so water can’t run down the cord into the outlet.

Problem 1: Water Too Hot (Heater Stuck On)

This is the most dangerous heater failure. Signs are fish breathing fast at the surface, a thermometer reading above about 84°F, and a heater light that stays on.

  1. Unplug the heater now.
  2. Turn off the aquarium light and open the lid to let heat escape.
  3. Add extra air. Warm water holds less oxygen.
  4. Cool the water slowly, a couple of degrees an hour. Float sealed bags of ice or frozen water bottles in the tank, or do a small water change with slightly cooler, dechlorinated water. Don’t dump ice straight in.
  5. Replace the heater. A heater that stuck on once can do it again.

Prevention: use a heater sized for your tank, not one far too big, and keep a separate digital thermometer where you can see it. For extra protection on valuable fish, an external temperature controller cuts power to the heater if it overheats.

Problem 2: Water Too Cold (Heater Not Heating)

Work through these in order:

  1. Power: is it plugged in, is the power strip on, and has a GFCI outlet tripped? Press the reset button.
  2. The light: most heaters have a light that comes on while heating. No light at all, with power at the outlet, usually means the heater is dead.
  3. The setting: check that the dial wasn’t bumped. Many adjustable heaters run from about 68 to 88°F. Preset heaters, like the Tetra HT, only hold about 78°F and can’t be turned up.
  4. Your thermometer: stick-on strips can be off by several degrees. Check with a second thermometer before you replace anything.
  5. Size: a heater that is too small for the tank, or for a cold room, may run all the time and still fall behind. See the sizing chart below.
  6. Placement: put the heater near the filter outflow or another spot with good water movement so warm water spreads through the tank.

Problem 3: Light Blinking, Red or Off

Lights mean different things on different brands, so check your heater’s manual first. In general, a light that is on means the heater is heating and a light that is off means it reached the set temperature. Some heaters, like the Aqueon submersible heaters, shut themselves off if they overheat and reset after they cool down. Blinking can be a warning that the heater is out of water or overheated. Unplug it, let it cool in the water, and plug it back in. If the warning keeps coming back, replace it.

Problem 4: Cracked Glass or Water Inside

If you see a crack, water inside the tube, or you feel a tingle when you touch the water, unplug everything right away. That is an electrical hazard to you and your fish. Throw the heater away and replace it. A hygger Fish Guard heater, or another heater with a protective guard, is a good choice if you keep large or boisterous fish.

Problem 5: The Temperature Swings Up and Down

  • A heater that is too small can’t keep up on cold nights.
  • A heater that is too big can overshoot.
  • Drafts, windows, heating vents and sunlight all push the temperature around. Move the tank if you can.
  • A lid keeps heat in and cuts swings a lot.

What Size Heater Do You Need?

A common rule is about 3 to 5 watts per gallon. Use the higher end if your room is cool or the tank has no lid. On tanks of 40 gallons and up, two smaller heaters are safer than one big one. If one sticks on, it can’t overheat the tank as quickly, and if one fails, the other keeps the water warm.

Tank size Heater size At Walmart (sold by Walmart)
5 gallons 25 watts Vibrant Life 25W
10 gallons 50 watts Vibrant Life 50W or Aqueon 50W
20 gallons 75 to 100 watts Vibrant Life 100W or Aqueon 100W
29 to 30 gallons 100 to 150 watts Aqueon Adjustable PRO 150W
40 gallons 150 to 200 watts Vibrant Life 200W or Marineland Visi-Therm 200W
55 gallons 200 to 300 watts, or two 150W heaters Aqueon Adjustable PRO 300W, or two 150W heaters

Other good options: the hygger digital mini heater for small tanks, and the Eheim Jager (also on eBay), a long-time favorite of many fish keepers.

When to Replace a Heater

  • It stuck on, even once.
  • The glass is cracked or water got inside.
  • It can’t hold the temperature you set, even in the right size tank.
  • It’s several years old and starting to act up. A heater costs far less than a tank of fish.

Many fish keepers keep a spare heater on hand so they can swap one in right away.

Frequently Asked Questions

What temperature should my tropical tank be?
Most tropical community fish do well around 76 to 80°F. Discus prefer warmer water, usually around 82 to 86°F.

Should my heater light be on all the time?
No. If it never turns off, either the heater is too small, the room is very cold, or the heater is stuck on. Check the water temperature with a thermometer right away.

Can I leave my heater on all the time?
Yes. Aquarium heaters are made to stay plugged in. The thermostat turns the heat on and off by itself.

Do I need a heater in summer?
Leave it in the tank. It only heats when the water drops below the setting, and it protects your fish on cool nights.

The Bottom Line

Hot water is the real emergency: unplug first, then cool slowly. Cold water is usually a power, setting or sizing problem. Size your heater at about 3 to 5 watts per gallon, use two on big tanks, always keep a separate thermometer, and replace any heater that cracks or sticks on.

Related guides:

Join the conversation in one of our Facebook Groups — share photos of your tank, ask questions, and connect with other tropical fish enthusiasts!

For Advanced Tropical Fish & Discus Keepers:
👉 JOIN DISCUS WHATEVER ON FACEBOOK

For Beginner Fish Keepers:
👉 JOIN BEGINNERS FISH KEEPERS ON FACEBOOK

 
Next Post
Ammonia or nitrite spike in an aquarium: emergency steps
Caring for Tropical Fish

Ammonia or Nitrite Spike in Your Aquarium? Emergency Steps to Save Your Fish

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *